In Defense of The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (and the series in general)

I wasn’t going to write a review of this movie, mostly because the focus of this site is Oscar-winning and/or nominated films and contenders, but I got several requests to do a proper review. I also wanted to write on the movie because I’ve noticed that a lot of the reviewers for this chapter, as well as the previous two, have had a negative bias whether they realize it or not (Richard Roeper, this time around, however said he liked the film and was entertained). This pre-disposition is something I don’t understand at all, as part of being a reviewer is to try to stand back and approach a film objectively. That being said, I have read the books and seen all the films, and although I realize that the writing in the books is less than stellar, there is something about them that I just love. What I think it is, is that they are entertaining. They are a form of escapism, and whether they are written well or no, they are enjoyable.  Same goes for the films. They are made to ENTERTAIN, not to enlighten, enrich or inspire us. Fans of the film series already know this. The books never claimed, nor tried to be, Pulitzer Prize quality and the films never tried to be Oscar worthy. What they did was entertain and from the sheer amount of money they’ve made, clearly they have done just that.

Now, the first film had a really low-budget, $37 mil, and a kind of kooky director in Catherine Hardwicke. It also had the unfortunate task of setting up the story as well as containing perhaps the most inane part of the story – the early courtship of Bella and Edward. I think the film suffered from a combination of poor screenplay and a bad fit with the director. The pacing is off and most of the performances, Billy Burke’s Charlie being one of the few exceptions, feel stilted. Regardless the film made over $400 mil at the world-wide box office and made its stars overnight sensations. The second film was based on the weakest of the first three books (I’m not even going to get into how bizarre and different the fourth books is from all the others). However, this time they had a bigger budget, $50 mil, and got to utilize one of the three young actors who really has some talent a lot more – Taylor Lautner. His performance stole the second film for sure. The soundtrack was miles better than the one from the previous film and all around the production value increased. Chris Weitz tried his best, but the film suffered a bit from how being at times insanely melodramatic and at other times chock full of action, but really that’s how the book goes too. What works in a book doesn’t always work on film and that ended up being a bit of a problem, although everything included in the film was necessary for the plot of the entire series to move forward. Regardless of its problems, it grossed over $700 mil at the world-wide box office.

Which brings me to the third film in the series, which opened at midnight on June 30th and took in over $68 mil in its first 24 hours. I definitely feel not only is it the best film in the series, it is the best adaptation from the original source material. This time I think Summit finally found a director who was a perfect fit in David Slade. His previous films, Hard Candy and 30 Days of Night, were edgy and full of great performances. And while Eclipse is not edgy in comparison to those films, it is in comparison to the previous films in the series. It’s violent and dark in all the right places. But also, being a romance at its core, the scenes involving the love triangle are dealt with subtly and actually feel natural and tender for the first time in the series. Slade also managed to get good performances out of his entire cast, something both previous directors were unable to do.

One thing about Bella that most non-fans don’t think fans know – she is an idiot, more so in the books than in the films. One thing I have to say about all three films is that they managed to make Bella way less annoying than she was in the books. There’s only a little of her inane narration in the films, as opposed to hundreds and hundreds of pages in the books. I think what a lot of what fans like about the books has nothing to do with its ridiculous heroine, but rather the impossibly romantic situation in which she finds herself. It’s about escapism and whether you like the heroine or no, you can appreciate the situation. It’s a romantic fantasy in the middle of the fantasy world of vampires and werewolves, which adds a little danger. And let’s face it, what’s better than romance with a little danger?

I don’t think Kristen Stewart was the best choice for this role, but we’re stuck with her at this point. And at least with this last film she’s finally bearable. Although, I think that had a lot to do with the fact that this film barely focused on her character at all. However, when she was on the screen, her performance was much improved from the previous films and I think that had a lot do with the changing of directors.

I really did not like Pattinson as Edward in the previous films, aside from maybe that scene in the first film with the Ray-Bans and everyone staring at them in the parking lot, but in Eclipse I do. He never once irritated me, even though his lines were just as ridiculous as they had been in the previous films. This I definitely attribute to Slade. Clearly he was able to find a way to coax better line deliveries and a little bit of actual acting out of his star. I particularly enjoyed the scene wherein Edward talks about how if he had met Bella in the era he was from, he’d have courted her properly. It was touching and completely believable.

Taylor Lautner was completely underused in the first film and stole the show in the second film, but in Eclipse he really  came into his own. I read one review that said he had the elusive “it factor” and I completely agree. He has major screen presence and charm. He manages to make his fantastical story line completely believable. Also there is way more chemistry in his scenes with Stewart than Pattinson’s with the actress. His passion is far more believable and feels so much more real. He also has great comic timing (something he also showcased earlier this year on Saturday Night Live). His little quips of sarcasm and wry humor are delivered perfectly. I think of the series’ three main stars he has the most promise to someday be a great star in his own right.

Billy Burke’s Charlie has been my favorite thing in the series since the very first film. In the books Charlie is nothing, he’s there solely so that Bella has a reason to come to Forks and a place to live while there. In the films, however, he is much more. At times he adds bits of much needed humor and at other times he is tender and sincere. His love for his daughter is palpable, as is his regret over  his previous role, or lack there of, in her life. I’m not sure how much of this improvement in the character is thanks to Melissa Rosenberg’s screenplays or Burke’s own interpretation of the character. Regardless, Burke’s performance as Charlie is strong in all three films, proving that the performance is his own.

I still think it is odd to change actresses for the role of Victoria when Eclipse is the last in the series with the character. However, Bryce Dallas Howard slips into the role just fine. I don’t have much more to say about her performance, but I thought it was worth noting that the change in actresses didn’t hinder the film in any way.

Newcomer Xavier Samuel was perfectly wicked as villainous rogue vampire Riley. To be honest, I barely remember this character from the book, so I can’t do much of a comparison. But as a new addition to the story, he’s wonderful. It’s with this story line that Slade’s previous work in horror really gets to shine. His Seattle is dark and harrowing and the mania involved with the newborn vampires feels like something out of The Lost Boys.

I was really glad the films finally got to the backgrounds of Rosalie and especially of Jasper. He was always one of my favorites from the books, but in the first film the only Cullen, other than Edward, the audiences got to know anything about was Carlisle. In the second we got a little bit more of Alice, although her whole back-story is in the first book and I think is probably going to be completely dropped from the films. Jasper and actor Jackson Rathbone were really underused in the first two films and here in Eclipse we get to see so much more about him and he finally gets to be as awesome as the fans already knew he was.

Lastly, I wanted to say how much I love evil Dakota Fanning. I think Fanning is a wonderful actress in everything she does. I also love evil characters when they’re done well, and she does evil really well. I must say I also loved Michael Sheen in New Moon and look forward to more of him in Breaking Dawn.

Speaking of Breaking Dawn, I still have no idea how they are going to make that book into a film, or films rather. I think it’s a wise decision to split it into two films, as the book is huge. But while I was reading it, all I could think about was how unfilmable the whole thing was. Bill Condon is a great director, so maybe he can make it work. I guess we’ll just have to wait and see.


About Marya E. Gates

Cinephile to the max.

Posted on July 1, 2010, in Review and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 13 Comments.

  1. ♥ you cause you’re awesome!

  2. I’ve just lost all respect for you how could you ever even pretend those books have any value UGH you call yourself a film writer

    Just kidding, I saw Eclipse at midnight opening night. I definitely agree, it was the best thus far (and, alas, probably the best overall because I cannot imagine Breaking Dawn turning into a positive experience for anyone except tiny Seth Clearwater). Also, is it just me, or did Jasper’s accent only appear after his flashback? Maybe I just didn’t notice it, but he seemed totally non-regional before the flashback, and then whammo Texan during and after it.

    • 1. I know! the only positive thing I can think about BD is going to be Seth, because the rest of that book was just one ridiculous thing after another. oh man.

      2. I think it did show up after the flashback and hadn’t been there prior to it. But I am completely okay with that because a) it was hot and b) I just figured all the reminiscing made him nostalgic and thus he stopped trying to hide his accent.

      3. I hope by the time BD comes out I can at least see ONE of the films with you. It just won’t seem right otherwise :/

      • You know what would be great? If they decided to say screw you to Stephenie Meyer and that annoying quirk she has of building up to a battle that you never see. I mean – they definitely played up the action in this movie, and I thought it was great. I know there’s a difference between deciding to show off-screen action on-screen and just creating a battle out of absolutely nothing, but I can’t imagine how they’re going to fill two movies with the nothing that is Breaking Dawn’s plot.

      • Two enjoyable films, that is. There’s enough going on to fill that amount of time, I just don’t really want to watch two hours of Rosalie being obnoxious and Leah existing. I’d much rather watch new, interesting vampires fighting other interesting vampires.

  3. Splitting the book into two movies isn’t the best move. While the book is very very long not much happens in a lot of it. Bella’s pregnancy can be condensed very easily. The sex already isn’t going to be really addressed in the film so they can cut that down significantly. It makes sense splitting the last Harry Potter book into two films because there is so much content in all of those pages.

    • I think they only way to make a decent adaptation of Breaking Dawn in one film, it would have to be at least 3 hours long and that is just way too long for this type of film series.

  4. Ok girls. I am 59 years old and have: read the first book, seen the second movie, and now I saw Eclipse yesterday. First of all regarding the books – I refused to read the rest because she is such a bad writer – and I stayed up until 4 in the morning reading the first one because I couldn’t put it down. LOL She is a great storyteller.

    I had a good time at the second movie. We drove in snow 100 miles and half the women from our town were also there and it was fun. I looked around at the audience and realized something important – People like romance. Period. I thought New Moon was OK and I had a good time.

    Now, Eclipse is an actual good movie. Well paced, good direction, good acting. I was totally sucked in and freaked out when I though Seth-Wolf was being killed.

    The romance all three sides of the triangle worked. Jacob was very very intense – I think this kid is going places.

    I now am actually looking forward to the next movie instead of just accepting that I will be dragged to it.

  5. BTW I keep waiting for someone to bring up something important to me. The Native American angle in this story. Native Americans are the most marginalized population in our citizenry. They are mostly portrayed on screen in rediculous ways. In the old westerns they were just gutteral speaking savages usually played by anyone brunet. In contemporary-based TV shows (I never see them in movies) I often see them portrayed as higher beings with political agendas who talk in some kind of jargon-speak. ugh.

    Jacob’s group are portrayed like the Native Americans I know. They feel their separatness but they drive trucks and wear jeans and have jobs. This movie in particular employed a lot of Native American actors.

    I applaud Ms Meyers for this part of the plot and the way it is being portrayed in the films.

  6. YES! I’m so glad that someone brought up the native american thing. I went to school way back in grade one with Bronson P. (Jared….. I think lol) I obviously don’t talk to him now I don’t think hed remember me 😛 but I was soooooo suprised to see him on the film and he was saying exactly the same thing. He really likes it that Natives are shown as normal people and not stupid pieces of meat to be taken advantage of. I love that Bronson is in these films because everyone can see what a Canadian Native boy looks like lol. HAWT. I’m so glad that us Natives are finally being shown realistically and I’m so glad that my long lost aquantance is apart of it 😀

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention In Defense of The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (and the series in general) « the diary of a film awards fanatic --

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: