Film Noir and the Academy Awards

As part of the For The Love of Film (Noir) blogathon, I thought I would take a look at some Film Noir that got a little love from the Academy. Although the bulk of films considered “Film Noir” were low-budget films and were often considered at the time “B-pictures,” there were a handful of films, mostly made by already established directors and stars, that were acknowledged by the Academy. After the cut I’ll do a breakdown of nine categories wherein Film Noir shined.

EDIT – I somehow missed Crossfire (1947) when I put this together, but have since written about it for Oscar Vault Monday here.




Best Pictures: The Letter, The Maltese Falcon, Double Indemnity, Mildred Pierce, Sunset Blvd.

The interesting thing about this five Film Noirs that were nominated for Best Picture is that, aside from The Maltese Falcon, their main protagonists are women. I suppose you could argue that Double Indemnity‘s main character is Fred MacMurray, but I definitely think it’s Barbara Stanwyck’s character that makes the most impact. Also, all four of the lead actresses in those films received nominations for Best Actress. Joan Crawford, however, was the only actress to win.

Best Director: William Wyler – The Letter, Otto Preminger – Laura, Billy Wilder – Double Indemnity, Robert Siodmak – The Killers, Carol Reed – The Fallen Idol, John Huston – The Asphalt Jungle, Carol Reed – The Third Man, Billy Wilder – Sunset Boulevard

I think it’s interesting to note that a handful of these nominations came without a Best Picture nomination for the directors’ films. I always find it odd when a director gets a nomination when a film isn’t up for Best Picture. Also of note, both Billy Wilder and Carol Reed were nominated twice for their efforts in film noir and although they did not win for these films, they both at one point in their careers won Best Director Oscar

Best Actress: Bette Davis – The Letter, Barbara Stanwyck – Double Indemnity, Joan Crawford – Mildred Pierce, Gene Tierney – Leave Her to Heaven, Gloria Swanson – Sunset Blvd

Of these performances, only Gene Tierney’s film was not also up for Best Picture (though it did win Best Color Cinematography). Like I said earlier, Joan Crawford was the only actress to win Best Actress for a performance in a Film Noir.

Best Actor: John Garfield – Body and Soul, William Holden – Sunset Blvd

These are such different performances. Garfield was nominated for a performance in a boxing film (a popular subject for film noir) and Holden inBilly Wilder’s dark look at Hollywood.

Best Supporting Actress: Eve Arden – Mildred Pierce, Ann Blyth – Mildred Pierce, Claire Trevor – Key Largo, Nancy Olson – Sunset Blvd., Thelma Ritter – Pickup on South Street

This was one of six Best Supporting Actress nominations for Thelma Ritter, who sadly never won. Claire Trevor performance in Key Largo was the only one of these nominated performances to win.

Best Supporting Actor: James Stephenson – The Letter, Sydney Greenstreet – The Maltese Falcon, Clifton Webb – Laura, Richard Widmark – Kiss of Death, Sam Jaffe – The Asphalt Jungle, Erich von Stroheim – Sunset Blvd.

Some great performances in this category, although there’s not a winning one among them. I haven’t seen Kiss of Death, but from that photo of Richard Widmark alone I know I need to see it.

Best Screenplay: Maltese Falcon, Double Indemnity, Laura, Mildred Pierce, The Killers, The Fallen Idol, The Asphalt Jungle, The Blue Dahlia, Sunset Blvd., Ace In The Hole

This is a combination of adapted and original screenplays. Of the above screenplays only Sunset Blvd. won an Oscar. I wanted to picture Carol Reed and Graham Greene, though, because I love all of their collaborations.

Best Cinematography: The Letter, Laura, Double Indemnity, Mildred Pierce, Leave Her To Heaven, The Naked City, The Third Man, Sunset Blvd. The Asphalt Jungle

Perhaps the category with the most wins for film noir, Laura, The Naked City and The Third Man all won Best B&W Cinematography and Leave Her To Heaven won Best Color Cinematography. Also, interesting to note that The Third Man, Sunset Blvd. and The Asphalt Jungle were all nominated in the same year.

Best Film Editing: The Letter, The Killers, Odd Man Out, Body and Soul, The Naked City, Sunset Blvd., The Third Man

In this category, only Body and Soul and The Naked City won their Oscars. Body and Soul is notable for its influence on Martin Scorsese’s 1980 boxing biopic Raging Bull.

Did I miss anything? Are there some films you wished had gotten nominated or think were highly influential but got ignored by the Academy? Do you have any film noir recommendations? I’ve seen a lot (thank you very much, Noirvember), but I’m always looking for suggestions. Also, don’t forget to make a donation to the Film Noir Foundation. Every little bit helps.



About Marya E. Gates

Cinephile to the max.

Posted on February 15, 2011, in Classic Film, the Academy Awards and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 13 Comments.

  1. A seasonally appropriate and interesting take on the Films Noirs. I agree about Richard Widmark; I haven’t seen the film, either!

  2. Hi! Cinema-Fanatic…
    Thanks, for stopping by “Wonders in the Dark” in order to leave a comment. I’am a Film noir Fanatic” (Well, my true interests is in the memorabilia…However, I think they go hand-in-hand…)

    Therefore, There are so many films that I think should have been nominated. (My list Of favorite films is endless…)

    If you, don’t mind me saying so, but your blog is very nice and informative too!
    DeeDee ;-D

  3. Crossfire was nominated for Best Picture as well, yet you don’t mention it.

  4. Great idea. I liked what you did. I would have to consider The Lost Weekend as film noir. Best Picture winner, Best Actor, I think maybe Best Director. I think maybe Spellbound as well. And Posessed, which Joan Crawford was nominated for. Also Claude Rains was nominated for Supporting Actor for Notorious, which is noir to me.

  1. Pingback: Film Noir and the Academy Awards « the diary of a film awards fanatic | The Oscars LIVE

  2. Pingback: Film Noir and the Academy Awards « the diary of a film awards fanatic | The Oscars LIVE

  3. Pingback: Ferdy on Films

  4. Pingback: Film Noir and the Academy Awards « the diary of a film awards fanatic | I Film Channel

  5. Pingback: Daytona diary: Drafting is key at “NASCAR’s Super Bowl” – Denver Post |

  6. Pingback: World Spinner

  7. Pingback: Oscar Vault Monday – The Hustler, 1961 (dir. Robert Rossen) « the diary of a film awards fanatic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: